“Right on to raising happy, independent GEEKS! Rules and limits don’t stultify children any more than strict iambic pentameter stultified Shakespeare. Marybeth Hicks encourages parents to stick to their guns and buck the sexy/cynical/smart alec kiddie culture that most parents actually hate, but feel powerless to fight. I just hope it’s not too late for me and my own kids!”

Lenore Skenazy
Columnist, New York Sun

blog

Current Articles | Categories | Search | Syndication

The book is NOT “Bringing up misfits”

Published Sunday, August 03, 2008 in

share this post

Last week there was a lively discussion on the Wall Street Journal blog “The Juggle” about my book. Thanks to Stefanie Illgenfritz for bringing the book to the attention of Juggle readers – and as well for joining me on Wednesday’s edition of NPR’s “On Point with Tom Ashbrook” to discuss it.

I always knew my take on parenting would seem offbeat to some, and that’s OK. The fact that I define my family as “geeky” strikes some folks as unflattering, but it never seemed that way to me. We’re comfortable with who we are and around our house we try not to take ourselves too seriously, anyway.

But it turns out that many folks assume – at least in WSJ blog comments – that I’m advocating a parenting strategy that turns out social misfits. Ack! Nothing could be further from the truth!

Nor am I promoting the idea that parents should mold and control the personalities of their children. For some reason, saying that I think parents ought to monitor and limit the influence of media in the lives of their kids equates to some people the notion that I’m out to produce Stepford children who robotically respond to every parental command.

If you met any one of my four children, you’d know that my husband and I aren’t raising social misfits or adolescent automatons. They’re all lively, unique and outspoken. Moreover, the fact that we guide them in decision-making when they’re young has resulted in teens who make terrific decisions for themselves.

So why the misconceptions? I guess the word geek is more highly charged than I anticipated and some folks aren’t willing to use a label they view as unappealing. Others seem to think that an argument for strong, hands-on parenting suggests an authoritarian style.

All I can say is, you gotta read the book! My use of the word “geek” as an acronym for Genuine, Enthusiastic, Empowered Kids should tell you that I’m writing with a sense of humor and a point of view that puts kids’ authentic personalities and their ultimate autonomy at the forefront.

I do believe it’s time to redefine what’s cool for our kids rather than let the culture encroach into our homes with all its materialism and cynicism and celebrity. At our house, the alternative is bringing up geeks (and that’s a good thing!)


Comments
By Andrea @ Thursday, August 07, 2008 3:00 AM
MB, your book is an inspiration to parents and the children of the parents who have dedicated themselves to raising socially responsible, morally charged, fun-loving kids. Your thoughts are right on the mark and your humor is icing on the cake! Not to mention not one of your kids is anywhere near a social misfit. That's a reality I wish the world could see..or at least the readers of the WSJ blog. Keep up the good work and remember, there has not been greatness that never saw opposition.

By Barbara, Kansas City,MO @ Sunday, August 10, 2008 10:41 PM
I love your book! I find myself nodding in agreement and laughing because what you write hits home. I've had many situations happen with my children, that you have had happen with your children. If parents are complaining about your book, they probably feel threatened. They know what you are saying is true; they are being lazy. It takes a commitment, time and patience to raise your children with values. Most parents are so caught up in their own lives, they don't have time to be in their kids lives.
Our kids need us more than ever to be interested in what they are seeing, hearing and doing. Keep up the wonderful work!

By Lara Mayeux @ Sunday, August 24, 2008 6:59 PM
Marybeth, my scientific experience conducting research with adolescents and my own personal experience with teenage niece and nephew tell me that you are right on. The adolescent peer culture rewards nastiness, hypermaturity, and consumerism with status and power--what we call "perceived popularity" in my field (developmental psychology). I want something different for my child. My husband and I are reading your book and nodding "Yes" all over the place. We hope to raise our year-old daughter as a true GEEK!

By Ariel @ Friday, September 12, 2008 8:18 PM
I can't wait to read your book! I am raising 3 geeks and they are happy, healthy, smart and popular. In fact, I've started my own blog about raising kids with values and limiting screen time because sometimes I feel isolated in my parenting decisions and it is nice to rant now and then.

You might be interested in reading a book called "The Big Turnoff" by Ellen Currey-Wilson. She made the decision to limit TV and video games for her son and he is growing up to be a well adjusted geek, as well.

Click here to post a comment

appearing Thursdays on

appearing weekly in

read Marybeth's blog

All content within this web site © Marybeth Hicks 2008
Web site design: Web Ascender and HighPoint Design. Photography: Canfield Jenkins House of Photography

Login